The damage photos that made us look twice at an Etsy return

A man works at a laptop beside a wide format printer and rolls of film at Decords.

We nearly refunded a large wall decal on the strength of one photo. The buyer in the US said the parcel and the rolled vinyl inside had been badly cut in transit. Tracking showed a quick, successful delivery. A couple of days later the buyer wanted their money back, which is usually when I try to settle things quickly.

Something about this Etsy wall decal damage claim bothered me. The slash in the rectangular box and the cut in the rolled decal didn’t seem to line up. The edges of the cardboard looked blurred and the shadows sat oddly. I wondered whether somebody had altered the picture with an image tool. I couldn’t establish that from a photo.

A few days later we saw another complaint with a badly torn box. The cardboard texture looked strange again. The names were different but the postal codes matched. Plenty of people share a postal code, of course. It was the combination, in a month when we saw three similar complaints, that made me slow down.

I explained that we needed the damaged decal and its box to inspect the parcel and pursue a shipping claim with FedEx. I sent a prepaid return label and offered a full refund when the parcel came back. The buyer stopped replying. The parcel never came back, and no Etsy case was opened.

We still take damage seriously. For severe physical damage we now ask for a short video showing the item and the box from several angles, or offer a return for inspection. That gives us more to work with when we speak to the carrier. I still can’t say how those photos were made, but I am glad we asked one more question.