Two wall decal orders and a $300 Etsy refund dispute

A man sits at a laptop in a print workshop with boxes, labels and paperwork on the table.

One customer bought two wall decals from us on Etsy. One cost $50. The other was a larger, more complicated design priced at $300. The delivery addresses were different, so we made and packed them separately. Each had its own tracking number, and both arrived.

The customer wrote about the $50 decal, saying the design was wrong. We asked for a photo so we could see what had happened. The next thing we saw was an Etsy refund dispute about the $300 order. The picture supplied as evidence showed the cheaper decal. It certainly didn’t look like the design in the $300 listing, but that was because it came from the other order.

Etsy refunded $300 from our account. As far as we could tell, the buyer kept both decals. I can’t see what happened inside Etsy’s review or who made the decision. What I can see is which picture belongs to which order, and that the whole refund was charged to us. Purchase Protection didn’t contribute to this particular refund.

At the time of writing we were still appealing. We sent screenshots of the conversation, both tracking numbers and the parcel weights. We wanted somebody to put each photo next to the design and shipping record for that purchase. We didn’t have a final answer yet.

The detail I now pay attention to is the order number on the complaint itself. When one person buys several items, I keep the messages, design, photo and tracking together for each one. Different addresses are common enough. In this case it was the mismatch between the photo and the order that mattered.