What a $7.99 product taught me about Amazon FBA margins

A man in a dark sweater holding a metal shower curtain ring with rollers.

Before I tried sourcing a ready made product, I’d used Amazon’s warehouses for our own stickers. I thought I understood Amazon FBA margins. Then I found a small, sturdy household product with growing demand in Helium 10. It was a set of metal shower curtain rings with little rollers so the curtain could glide along the rail.

I wrote to about fifty suppliers on Alibaba. Thirty replied, ten would make a hundred sets and three offered a price worth testing. I ordered samples to Estonia, chose a supplier and designed packaging with the Amazon barcodes. The first hundred went to a US warehouse.

Nothing moved until I advertised. The ads took the profit, but the first batch sold in about a month. I ordered three hundred, then five hundred. Some customers found us without an ad, and for a while the figures looked encouraging.

Three or four months in, sales dried up. More advertising didn’t fix it. Other sellers had what looked like the same rings in similar boxes for less. I ordered a set and compared the two. My suspicion was that the same factory was supplying the competition or selling directly, although I couldn’t establish that.

A pack sold for $7.99. Amazon’s charges were roughly $5 and the goods plus shipping cost me about $2. That left 99 cents before advertising. Taking just 50 cents off the selling price swallowed half of what was left. I sold the remaining stock and stepped away from the product.

That was the real cost of choosing something anyone could source. I had enough sales to order more, but almost no room to respond when the price changed. Since then I look at what is left in cash per order as well as the percentage in a spreadsheet.