Why we once shipped a wall decal with an empty tube

A man holds two cardboard mailing tubes taped together beside a roller conveyor.

For years, shipping wall decals in cardboard tubes seemed like the obvious choice. A rolled decal fitted snugly, the tube was light and strong, and we’d ordered a pallet of them. Then, in the middle of our December rush, FedEx told us our round parcels would cost an extra €25 each from 1 January unless we changed the packaging.

Our account manager explained what happened on the sorting line. A tube about 60 cm long and 5 cm across could roll sideways, catch between the conveyor rollers and spin in place. The next parcels piled into it. Someone had to stop the line and pull it out by hand. Suddenly I understood why the carrier saw our neat little cylinder as an expensive shape.

The triangular FedEx box would have pushed a 100 gram sticker into a four kilogram volumetric weight charge. No supplier could make our new rectangular boxes in two weeks. We discussed end pieces and other shapes, but none of those suggestions worked for the carrier at the time.

So we taped two of our round tubes together. One held the decal. The other stayed empty, doing the very important job of stopping the first one rolling. Packing took about three times as long and used twice as many tubes. It also created a customer service problem I should have seen coming.

Some customers naturally opened the empty tube first. We’d then get a furious message saying we’d shipped them air. We had to ask them to open the tube taped alongside it. Their decal was in there all along.

About two months later our rectangular boxes arrived. We’ve used those for FedEx ever since. Omniva and DHL were still taking our round tubes when I wrote this. A parcel can do its job perfectly for the product and still be the wrong shape for the journey.