The Amazon FBA returns setting that caught out our window decals

A man applying black bird silhouette decals to a pane of glass.

One of my first Amazon FBA products was a set of black bird silhouettes for windows. We packed a hundred sets individually and sent them to a US warehouse. They sold out in a couple of months. We made another two hundred, sent them off, and I went on holiday.

An email arrived while I was away. Amazon had suspended the account, frozen our funds and asked us to remove our remaining stock. A customer had reported receiving used goods sold as new. These were single use vinyl decals. We wouldn’t have been able to peel one off a window and put it back in a new packet if we’d wanted to.

My first appeal asked Amazon to inspect the stock. A week later the reply upheld the decision and cited our order defect rate, which had gone over 1%. I had one appeal left. Reading other sellers’ experiences pointed me to the Amazon FBA returns setting I’d left at its default. A returned item could be put back on sale if it appeared new at inspection.

That gave me a possible explanation. Someone might have opened a packet, creased the decals or tried one, then returned it. An apparently tidy bag could have gone back on the shelf and reached a second customer. I couldn’t see the warehouse history myself, so in my final appeal I asked Amazon to trace that particular order and examine the rest of the batch.

Another week passed before Amazon said the investigation was complete and restored the account. I changed the returns setting straight away. I never got a minute by minute account of what happened in that warehouse, but a visual check of a packet was a poor match for a product that could only be applied once. It took most of a holiday to understand that.