How an AI wall decal design led to a Jeep complaint on Etsy

Some of our US customers like wall decals that make an object look as if it’s coming through the wall. I wanted to add an off road vehicle emerging from a forest at night. We used ChatGPT to explore the idea and Midjourney to produce illustrations. Before listing them, we looked for logos and recognisable references to films or car brands. Nothing jumped out at us.
The AI wall decal design still attracted an intellectual property complaint. The Etsy notice named FCA US LLC, the company associated with the Jeep brand. The registration mentioned in the notice showed a grille with seven upright slots. I enlarged our illustration and counted nine, more oval than rectangular to my eye. I also saw a decorative sticker where the registration I read referred to vehicles and parts.
Those were the differences I wanted to discuss. Counting the openings in an illustration couldn’t settle the question by itself. Etsy took down the listing and directed me to the claimant. I wrote once, followed up a week later and then offered to retire the design and confirm that in writing if they would withdraw the complaint. I received no reply.
I hired US lawyers who work on these cases. Their formal letter didn’t get a reply either. Their estimate for going to court ran into tens of thousands of dollars, far outside what I could spend on one wall decal. At the time I wrote this, the warning was still on our account.
What bothered me most was never finding out whether a conversation could have resolved it. It also changed how I look at a generated picture. Now I pay attention to the outline and distinctive details as well as the badge. When a vehicle or scene immediately makes me think of a specific brand or film, I choose a different idea.
